Yet another review of Holeman and Finch Public House

Picture 071 (8)
    Ok, so I am obviously a little late to this party. Holeman and Finch Public House has been a foodie favorite in Atlanta since they opened and is possibly one of, if not the most, covered restaurants by my blogging brethren. I have been DYING to eat here for the longest time, but could never seem to convince my friends to head down there, partially because there is almost always a significant wait to deal with. So, I finally decided that I had put this off long enough, and flew solo for my first trip to the now famous gastropub. Fortunately, FoodieBuddha stopped by for a bit, so I wasn’t left to my own devices the whole time. (Yeah, I’m a name dropper. Big whoop, wanna fight about it?)

    For those that do not know, Holeman and Finch is widely known for having the single best burger that one can buy in Atlanta. And this burger is not only absent from the menu, but is only served after 10 PM every night (and during brunch service on Sundays). Part of the reason I have never been is that none of my friends want to go unless they can get the burger, and most can’t wait that late into the evening to eat. Well, let me assure you, if the burger is all that you know of H&F, you are in for a treat. There is so much more to this place than a well-crafted hamburger that it is staggering. So, if you came here for yet another review on Atlanta’s most popular burger, you will be disappointed. (That post is now located here)

    Fortunately, I arrived around 6PM, so I was able to pony right on up to the bar and dive into their impressive drink list. Greg Best, the house mixologist and part-owner with Chef Linton Hopkins, maintains a constantly changing menu of great house made cocktails. As with everything served here, from the ketchup to the cured meats, all of the cocktails utilize house-made ingredients that give the drinks an edge over their competition. I started my evening with a Badgers Hiss (Rittenhouse Rye, Becherovka, citrus punch, and seltzer water).

Badger's Hiss

Badger's Hiss

    Light, fruity, and satisfying. In addition to a few glasses of Pappy Van Winkle’s 20-year bourbon on the rocks (I’m a sucker for bourbon), I also put away a glass of The Shrub, which is a house made cranberry and ginger syrup, Gin, and lemon seltzer. I hate gin. But I loved this drink.

    Now for the food. Those of you that have read my reviews of Abbatoir know that I am not afraid of a little offal in my meals. So, the adventurous eater in me was immediately drawn to the “Parts” section of the menu. But if eating outside of the box isn’t for you, fear not. The offal portion of the menu is only a fraction of their offerings, so you won’t be forced outside of your culinary comfort zone if you aren’t up for that.

Picture 071 (1)

    I started things off with an order of Deviled Eggs Three Ways. You can ask any member of my family that has ever eaten a Christmas or Thanksgiving dinner with me – I F’ing love deviled eggs. These were fantastic. Unfortunately, I only wrote down two of the three “ways” the eggs were made – Country ham and Sunchoke. If you are one of those salt-sensitive people, the country ham might be a little too salty for you, but I ain’t one of those people. The Country Ham deviled eggs were my favorite of the bunch.

    Next up was the first off of the “parts” list, and all three dishes were Offal-y good. GET IT?!? OFFAL-Y GOOD?!?! (Holy shit, my own cheesiness overwhelms me sometimes).

Picture 071 (6)

Griddled Pork Belly

    I started things out by going with the first dish that caught my eye – the Griddled Pork Belly served on a Parker House roll, topped with Chow Chow. God DAMN I love pork belly. These were basically little pork belly sliders. The belly itself was sliced very thin, and this resulted in about 80% of the surface area being the tasty crust, which added a lot of flavor. I don’t think these things lasted more than 3 minutes in front of me.

Picture 071 (7)

    Next up was a suggestion from the bartender – Pan Roasted rabbit livers, sweet potato puree, and red wine apple butter. This was a great combination of fall flavors. This dish tasted like fried Thanksgiving. Loved it.

    Now, my next dish was a bit of a novelty buy – Veal Brains pan fried with lemon butter and home-made croutons. I’d never had brains and wanted to be able to say that I had. What shocked me the most about this dish was how much this reminded me of my mom’s pan fried veal cutlets that she used to make when I was a kid. Maybe it was the traditional pairing with the lemon butter. Either way, this didn’t have the organ-y flavor that I was expecting (I know…organ-y isn’t a word. Get over it). This dish tasted so much like veal, I completely forgot that I was eating brains.



    Finally, despite the fact that I was bursting at the seams already, I ordered the Hand Chopped Steak Tartar w/ farm egg, whole grain mustard, and shoestring potatoes. This was an excellent tartar. I think the overall “Oh my God this is so good” factor was probably diminished by the fact that, at this point, I was a little tipsy and extremely full. But there was nothing I could complain about. Full or not, I enjoyed the hell out of it.

Picture 071 (5)

    Holeman and Finch is a guaranteed good time. The atmosphere is awesome, the food is satisfying, and the drinks go down oh-so-well. I had a great time, and I went by myself. And I can’t wait to go back.

Holeman & Finch Public House on Urbanspoon

This entry was posted in Atlanta Dining and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.


  1. Posted November 5, 2009 at 10:25 pm | Permalink

    Sounds like one helluva meal. You’re not late to the party at all because I haven’t been yet 😛
    Have you tried fried veal sweetbreads? Those are delicious also…getting midnight cravings now after reading this…

    • LTF
      Posted November 6, 2009 at 7:08 am | Permalink

      I have not had the fried sweetbreads there (had to choose between that or the rabbit livers), but I am no stranger to sweetbreads. I’m a big fan. As long as they still have them, I’ll give them a go next time.

  2. Posted November 6, 2009 at 6:39 am | Permalink

    Hey-there’s an easy answer to the burger problem. Go on Sunday for brunch. The same burgers are served in much less limited quantities.

    • LTF
      Posted November 6, 2009 at 7:09 am | Permalink

      Yeah, I know….I’m usually craving some sort of breakfast food when sunday brunch comes around, so I never think about H&F and the burger in the moment. But, realistically, Sunday brunch will probably be when I finally get my burger fix from here…

  3. Katherine McIntosh
    Posted November 8, 2009 at 2:41 am | Permalink

    I love that H&F has a “parts” section on their menu. I mean, it is so in your face… Those who are not interested can avoid, as opposed to those who look at a full menu and go “ewwww” when the chicken is next to the brain… lol

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

  • Pages

  • Categories

  • Archives

Get Adobe Flash playerPlugin by wordpress themes
Live To Feast Atlanta restaurants